Skip to Main Content

The 8 best cheap pet insurance companies for May 2025

Updated May 06, 2025

With rising veterinary costs, even routine pet care can strain your budget. Finding affordable pet insurance that doesn't compromise coverage can be a challenge. By comparing providers and understanding the key features of each, you can find a policy that balances affordability with suitable care for your pet.

The Bankrate team has put together this guide to highlight some of the best cheap pet insurance companies. We focused on those that offer solid coverage at lower prices. Whether you're looking for a plan with digital ease like Lemonade or specialized coverage for exotic pets from Nationwide, we’ve gathered the top contenders to help you make an informed decision. Let's dive into what makes each company stand out and how to get the best value for your money.

Best cheap pet insurance companies

Star Icon

Featured Bankrate Partner

Logo

4.6

Rating: 4.6 stars out of 5
Logo

4.1

Rating: 4.1 stars out of 5
Logo

4.4

Rating: 4.4 stars out of 5
Logo

4.5

Rating: 4.5 stars out of 5
Logo

4.3

Rating: 4.3 stars out of 5
Logo

4.6

Rating: 4.6 stars out of 5
Logo

4.6

Rating: 4.6 stars out of 5
Logo

4.7

Rating: 4.7 stars out of 5

What is the average cost of pet insurance?

According to a 2023 report by the North American Pet Health Insurance Association (NAPHIA), the average cost of accident and illness insurance for dogs was $56.30 monthly or $675.61 annually. For accident-only coverage, the monthly average was $17.01, and the annual average was $204.16.

The average insurance cost for a cat with accident and illness coverage was $31.94 monthly or $383 annually. Accident-only coverage costs an average of $9.68 monthly and $116.11 annually.

Pet insurance premiums are calculated based on multiple factors and can vary across pet insurance companies and their policies.

How can you find the best cheap pet insurance company?

The top pet insurance companies have different strengths and highlight features. You may need to shop around to find the right fit for your four-legged friend’s health care needs and your budget. The following tips can help guide your search.

1. Compare multiple providers

Don’t settle for the first company you come across. Use comparison tools to evaluate several pet insurance companies based on factors that are important to you, such as price and coverage.

2. Look for customizable plans

Many pet insurance companies offer customizable plans that allow you to adjust the coverage, deductible and reimbursement rate. Lowering the reimbursement rate or increasing the deductible can reduce your premium while still offering solid coverage.

3. Consider accident-only plans

If your budget is tight, accident-only plans are typically much cheaper than comprehensive policies. Although these plans cover injuries from accidents like broken bones or poison ingestion, be mindful that they don't cover illnesses or conditions such as hereditary or congenital issues.

4. Review exclusions carefully

Some cheaper plans may exclude specific conditions or treatments. Look out for breed-specific exclusions, waiting periods or limits on hereditary and congenital conditions. Essentially, be sure you're not buying coverage you don't want or need.

5. Check for discounts

Look for companies that offer discounts. Common discounts to look out for include (but may not be limited to) military or veteran perks, discounts for essential workers or healthcare professionals, multiple pet discounts, or benefits for vets, staff and volunteers working at animal welfare organizations.

6. Pay attention to the age limits

Some companies charge higher premiums or offer less coverage for older pets. If you have a senior pet, search for providers that cater to aging animals without charging exorbitant rates. Also, make sure to find out how the premium might increase as your pet ages.

7. Read customer reviews

Customer reviews can provide insights into the company’s claims process, customer service and overall value. Look for feedback from pet owners who have filed claims to see if the provider lives up to its promises.

8. Shop around

Most pet insurance companies offer instant quotes online. Input your pet's details and compare prices. Be sure you understand the terms of canceling your policy if you find a better deal later.

How can you save money on pet insurance?

Deciding on an affordable pet insurance option means balancing the premium costs with the level of coverage and service quality. When choosing a pet insurance plan, you can consider some of the following methods that might decrease your premium:

  • Start with a basic plan. If budget is your primary concern, you can choose a lower-tier plan and upgrade later if you want to.
  • Look for discounts. Discounts, such as those for insuring multiple pets or opting for annual payments, can reduce your costs. 
  • Choose a higher deductible. The annual deductible — the amount you pay out-of-pocket before insurance kicks in—also plays a role in determining your insurance premiums. Higher deductibles typically lower your premiums. 
  • Pick a lower reimbursement rate. Reimbursement rates determine the percentage of vet bills you get back. Higher reimbursement rates typically mean higher premiums.
  • Get lower maximum coverage. The maximum coverage amount refers to the cap on how much the insurer will pay annually. Choosing a lower maximum coverage will translate to more affordable premiums.

Is pet insurance worth the cost?

Even when you find cheaper pet insurance plans, you may wonder if you're better off just paying for your pet's healthcare out of pocket. Deciding whether pet insurance is worth it comes down to a few key factors.

Assess how your pet’s age, breed, overall health and potential risk factors might come into play. Pet insurance typically won’t cover pre-existing conditions, and some policies may exclude breed-specific health issues.

Understanding how pet insurance works and what coverage each type offers is important. Some plans limit payouts per condition, per year or over the pet's lifetime. It's also important to understand what portion of your vet bills your insurance provider will reimburse you for and how long the process will take. 

Ask your vet whether insurance is the right option for your pet. Vets and their administrative staff can give you a good idea of which companies are more likely to pay out when you submit a claim. Then, weigh the cost of insurance against potential vet bills and long-term care expenses. Compare these to alternatives such as setting up a pet savings account.

Ultimately, your choice should align with your risk tolerance and your pet’s health needs. You can spare yourself a lot of frustration and potential heartbreak by shopping around, reading the fine print and knowing what you're paying for when you sign the dotted line.

Frequently asked questions

Methodology