Rising tides and insurance costs: Coastal homeowners navigate high coverage costs

When Jack Nelson purchased his dream home along the canals of Long Beach, New York, he imagined the best of both worlds: an ocean in his backyard and the bustling metropolis of New York City a quick train ride away. What he didn’t envision was the insurance headache. Following Hurricane Sandy, he told Bankrate that insurers in his area tightened their coverage requirements for homes along the water. Securing affordable home and flood insurance was a massive undertaking. To pull it off, Nelson chose to lift his home ten feet up and build a new insurance-compliant foundation.

Nelson is not the only coastal homeowner facing major home insurance hangups. The increasing frequency and severity of climate-related disasters have changed how insurers approach coverage; in certain states, many of the best home insurance companies have limited coverage or stopped writing policies for homes near the water.

Data and statistics: The cost of living in a coastal area

There are many different considerations that factor into home insurance costs, one of the largest being the risk of filing a claim. Most coastal areas have always presented some level of risk to insurers, but the uptick in extreme weather has exacerbated the issue. Now, with the risk of storms, flooding, hurricanes and other catastrophic natural disasters running high, many coastal homeowners are left to choose between seeking out limited and costly home coverage or leaving their home financially vulnerable to a potentially catastrophic disaster.

In an environment where it seems everything is getting more expensive and coverage options are becoming more limited, homeowners with roots along the water may need to reassess their budgets to afford coverage.

Insurance companies’ response to climate-related disasters

Extreme climate events caused upwards of $25 billion in damage in 2023, and climate experts predict that these events will only become more common and intense in the coming years. Insurers are already struggling to remain solvent in some coastal states, which in turn leads to limitations — and even complete pauses — in writing new policies. The ramifications of insurers leaving a state can extend far beyond just a few policyholders. Licensed insurance agent Shannon Martin explains more in-depth:

In the past three years, Florida has seen around 30 insurers exit the state. California homeowners are also witnessing some of the state’s largest insurance companies pull out, and several Louisiana home insurers have been declared insolvent in the hurricane-prone state. Although the exact scenario for each state is different, all three can point to extreme weather as one of the catalysts for the insurance exodus.

Homeowners struggle in coastal areas

John Steuer has owned a coastal home in Long Island for 40 years and has never filed a home insurance claim. His home in Rocky Point is above sea level and has not experienced any type of flooding. While shopping for a home insurance policy, he made an in-person visit to an insurance office. After looking up his address, his application was flat-out rejected by the carrier.

Despite his flawless home insurance record, Steuer had to seek out an insurance broker in order to find coverage. Further, he had to use a non-local company. And coverage was not cheap — he tells Bankrate that his high home insurance costs have gobbled up part of his disposable income budget.

Finding coverage is only half the battle. Florida has one of the toughest home insurance markets in the country, with insurers departing the state in droves and the average cost for $250,000 in dwelling coverage an eye-popping 39 percent higher than the national average. Jeff Ostrowski, a Florida homeowner and home lending writer for Bankrate, explains the lengths he went to maintain his coverage:

Government support for high-risk areas

Homeowners in high-risk areas who struggle to purchase coverage in the private insurance market do have other options. For home insurance, there’s the FAIR plan, which can provide insurance coverage as a last-resort option. Coverage under the FAIR plan is pretty limited; generally, only dwelling and personal property coverage are provided on a named-peril basis.

For flood insurance, homeowners can look to the National Flood Insurance Plan (NFIP). Like the FAIR plan, coverage under the NFIP is more limited compared to what is available from a private insurer. Generally, only dwelling and personal contents are protected, and coverage limits tend to be lower: dwelling is capped at $250,000 and contents at $100,000.

Government-backed plans can provide solutions for some homeowners, but what about homeowners who need coverage beyond what these plans can offer and cannot find an insurer that will write them a policy? In many states, the FAIR plan is already overburdened. Because it is specifically for high-risk homes, premiums tend to be higher than average.

The way forward is murky. Insurance regulations are often left up to the state, as opposed to the national government, and a solution to filling the insurance gap will vary depending on the state. In California, for instance, private insurers are restricted in how much they can raise rates per year. With insurers unable to raise rates to meet the heightened climate-related risks, many have had no choice but to stop writing new policies in the state. In this case, reevaluating these rate restrictions could incentivize more insurers to return to the Golden State.

In other cases, funding can help. In early 2023, the Louisiana state legislature passed a bill that grants $45 million to help stabilize the home insurance market, hoping to lessen the burden on the Louisiana Citizens’ government-backed insurance program and get more private insurers to return to the state.

Frequently asked questions

• • What insurance do you need for a beach house?

    Home insurance is not a legal requirement, but if you have a mortgage on your home, your financial lender will likely require you to carry home insurance. Coastal homeowners are usually required to also have flood insurance. Depending on where you live, you may also consider windstorm insurance, which is fairly common in states like Florida and Texas. Otherwise, the amount of insurance you need for a beach house will depend on factors like your home’s location, whether it’s your primary residence, your cost to rebuild and more.Learn more: How much homeowners insurance do I need?

  • Why is coastal insurance so expensive?

    To put it simply, insurance premiums are calculated based on risk: the higher your risk of filing a home insurance claim, the higher your insurance premium will likely be. Even though standard home insurance policies do not cover flood damage, homeowners in coastal areas are at an elevated risk of wind damage, hurricanes and other natural catastrophes that could lead to expensive insurance claims. To make up for the added risk of insuring a home along the water, home insurers generally charge higher rates.

  • Is my coastal home protected from flooding?

    Almost all home insurance policies exclude flood damage. To be financially protected from a flood, you would need to purchase flood insurance through a private carrier or through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). Keep in mind that most NFIP flood insurance policies require a 30-day waiting period before coverage takes effect.