Cheapest car insurance in Maine for 2024

In the Pine Tree State, the average cost of full coverage car insurance is $1,562 per year, while the average cost of minimum coverage stands at $416 per year. When hunting for cheap car insurance in Maine, note that individual rating factors can influence the rates you're offered. Regardless, several carriers consistently provide lower-than-average rates for diverse driver profiles in ME.

Key takeaways

• Cheapest company for minimum coverage: USAA
• Cheapest company for full coverage: USAA
• Cheapest company for drivers with prior incidents: Geico and Vermont Mutual
• Cheapest company for young drivers: MMG and Geico

Opting for a liability-only or minimum coverage policy might seem like a cost-effective approach for Maine drivers. While doing so can be lighter on the wallet, it’s important to point out that these policies offer limited financial protection. For drivers keen on paying the lowest possible price, USAA stands out as one of the cheapest car insurance companies in Maine for minimum coverage.

Minimum coverage requirements for Maine drivers

Car insurance laws in Maine mandate that all licensed drivers have a minimum amount of coverage so other road users are protected financially in the event of an accident you cause. Here's a breakdown of the state's requirements:

• $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident in bodily injury liability coverage
• $25,000 in property damage liability coverage
• $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident in uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage
• $2,000 per person in medical payments coverage

Interestingly, despite Maine's somewhat extensive minimum requirements, its average car insurance rates are notably lower than many other U.S. states. As such, many insurance experts advise drivers to consider adding more coverage if financially feasible. 

Investing in full coverage car insurance, for instance, provides broader financial protection in the event of an accident and could amount to significantly lower out-of-pocket costs for vehicle repairs or replacements, and other damage. That’s because minimum insurance only covers damage and injuries other drivers and their passengers incur if you cause an accident, whereas full coverage may help pay for damage you incur.

Securing cheap Maine auto insurance doesn’t mean you’ll be stuck with a minimum coverage policy. Many drivers here have access to lower-than-average premiums for full coverage, as well. 

Full coverage typically includes comprehensive and collision insurance on top of your state’s minimum insurance requirements to cover a wider array of potential risks on the road. USAA is among the cheapest insurance companies in ME in this segment, consistently offering competitive average rates for full coverage.

Drivers with prior incidents often face heightened insurance rates due to the perceived risk in insuring them. Whether it's an at-fault accident, a speeding ticket or a DUI, blemishes on a driver's record can significantly impact premiums for several years. Given this fact, it's especially important for affected drivers to research and identify insurers that still offer competitive pricing despite past infringements. Luckily, there are a few options available for cheap Maine auto insurance for drivers with prior incidents.

• Cheapest car insurance for drivers with a ticket: Geico
• Cheapest car insurance for drivers with an at-fault accident: Vermont Mutual
• Cheapest car insurance for high-risk drivers: USAA

Cheapest insurance companies for drivers in Maine with a speeding ticket: Geico

A speeding ticket conviction in Maine will likely increase your car insurance rates, even if you switch carriers. Car insurance companies typically see speeding tickets as an indication of risky driving behavior and increase rates accordingly. If you do have a recent speeding ticket on your record, you might find low rates with these five carriers:

Cheapest car insurance for drivers in Maine with an at-fault accident: Vermont Mutual

Car accidents can lead to costly claim payouts for car insurance companies, so they typically charge higher rates for drivers who have been involved in accidents — especially at-fault accidents. The following five companies may offer low rates for drivers with an at-fault accident on their record.

Cheapest car insurance in Maine for high-risk drivers: USAA

High-risk drivers see some of the highest average car insurance rates. You might be considered a high-risk driver if you have a DUI conviction (also called an OUI in Maine). Other potential high-risk infractions include multiple speeding tickets, multiple accidents or driving without insurance. We analyzed rate data for a driver with a single DUI conviction to find the cheapest companies for high-risk drivers. Note that not all carriers will extend coverage to a driver with a DUI, though.

As in many states, age plays a significant role in determining car insurance rates. Young adults, especially those in their teens and early 20s, often face higher premiums due to their inexperience on the road. Statistics indicate that younger drivers are more prone to accidents and risky driving behaviors, leading insurers to categorize them as high-risk. As a result, insurance companies charge higher rates to mitigate potential payouts. However, as young drivers age and gain more driving experience — especially if they maintain clean driving records — they can expect their premiums to gradually decrease.

• Cheapest car insurance for insuring a teen driver: MMG
• Cheapest car insurance for teens with a ticket: Vermont Mutual
• Cheapest car insurance for teens with an at-fault accident: Vermont Mutual
• Cheapest car insurance for young drivers with a DUI: USAA

Cheapest Maine car insurance for insuring a teen driver: MMG

While youth brings vitality and energy, it often comes with steeper car insurance costs in Maine. Insurers typically view teen drivers as high-risk due to their limited time behind the wheel. The brighter side? Many insurance companies offer discounts for students who maintain good grades or complete driver education programs. By taking advantage of these teen discounts and demonstrating responsible driving habits, teen drivers can work toward more favorable rates as they mature into seasoned motorists.

Cheapest Maine car insurance for teens with a ticket: Vermont Mutual

For teen drivers in Maine, receiving a speeding ticket not only serves as a hard lesson on road safety but also is likely to significantly impact their insurance premiums. Given their already elevated risk profile due to age and inexperience, a traffic violation exacerbates insurers' concerns. Consequently, insurance companies tend to hike rates substantially after such incidents.

However, amidst this, some carriers offer more affordable options. In the realm of post-ticket insurance for teens, USAA stands out by offering some of the cheapest auto insurance in Maine, providing a silver lining for parents looking to manage costs after such an event.

Cheapest Maine car insurance for teens with an at-fault accident: Vermont Mutual

In Maine, an at-fault accident on a teen's driving record can lead to a substantial rise in insurance costs. As previously mentioned, young drivers already face elevated rates due to their inexperience and perceived high risk. Adding an accident intensifies this. However, there's some relief. Vermont Mutual offers comparatively affordable rates for teens with at-fault accidents, making them a top choice for cheap car insurance in ME.

Cheapest Maine car insurance for young drivers with a DUI:  USAA 

A DUI conviction for young drivers significantly hikes insurance premiums due to their inherent elevated risk profile. This infraction pushes them further into the high-risk category in insurers’ eyes. Despite this challenge,  USAA  stands out as the most budget-friendly option for young drivers with a DUI on their record. Although it may feel like your back is against the wall, it’s important to shop wisely and consider future behavior, as maintaining a clean record can gradually reduce your insurance costs over time.

Every insurer has its own discount opportunities and eligibility requirements, but most auto insurers offer ways to save on your premium. Experts recommend speaking with an agent to find out what’s on offer. Below are some of the more commonly available car insurance discounts in Maine:

• Young driver discounts: Students and young drivers may earn a discount with certain carriers if they take a safe driving course, earn good grades or leave their car at home while away at college.
• Safe driver discounts: You might save as a safe driver by taking a driver safety course or demonstrating safe habits through a telematics program.
• Claims-free discounts: Some insurance companies offer discounts to drivers who have gone a specified amount of time without filing a claim.